Thistle Subscribe

Labs

Our AI-driven analysis of Bitcoin’s cycles: the correlations between today’s market and every earlier year, cycle and bear market, with the measures and the macro data behind them.

Updated just now

$73,548 price now -41.0% from the cycle's closing high 46% through cycle 4 517 days to the halving 402 days since the top Details

Is Bitcoin cheap or dear right now?

Seven ways of setting today’s price against something slow: a long average, a growth line, what miners earn, what holders paid. Each reading is placed in its own history, from the cheapest it has been to the dearest, with what the following 12 months did after readings like today’s.

to 12 Nov
All seven together, Bitcoin is
on the cheap side dearer than 32% of its own history, cheaper than 68%
Price now
$73,548 12 Nov 2026
For comparison, any 12 months
+75% the middle result of every 12-month period since 2015, good and bad together
Next 12 months, after readings like today’s: the middle result
Price against its 200-week average 1.08 times its 200-week average
cheap dearer than 14% of its history
Next 12 months, the middle result +126% up 100% of the time, 5 periods
Price against its long-term growth line 0.50 times its long-term growth line
on the cheap side dearer than 20% of its history
Next 12 months, the middle result +139% up 100% of the time, 4 periods
Bitcoin's value against everything miners have been paid 15.5 times all miner pay to date
in the middle dearer than 60% of its history
Next 12 months, the middle result +77% up 80% of the time, 6 periods
Price against what holders paid 1.37 times what holders paid on average
on the cheap side dearer than 31% of its history
Next 12 months, the middle result +134% up 95% of the time, 4 periods
Price against its 2-year average 0.82 times its 2-year average
cheap dearer than 19% of its history
Next 12 months, the middle result +120% up 91% of the time, 5 periods
Miners' daily income against its yearly average 0.97 times its yearly average
in the middle dearer than 42% of its history
Next 12 months, the middle result +49% up 66% of the time, 9 periods
Price against its 200-day average 1.01 times its 200-day average
on the cheap side dearer than 37% of its history
Next 12 months, the middle result +47% up 57% of the time, 6 periods

How to read this

  • The scale runs from the cheapest each measure has ever been to the dearest. The marker is today. The place is worked out from that measure’s past only, as it stood on each day, so hindsight does not flatter it.
  • "After readings like this" takes the tenth of days since 2015 whose reading was closest to today’s and shows what the next 12 months did. Bitcoin has risen a great deal over those years, which lifts every middle result: compare each with the figure for any 12 months above.
  • What it is for: a sense of where the price stands in the long run. It says nothing useful about next week or next month, and it rests on three or four market cycles. Not advice and not a forecast.

Price against its 2-year average, over time

The average price over the last two years.

0.82× now
Bitcoin price measure in the cheapest tenth of its history so far measure in the dearest tenth the measure itself (lower panel)
$10$100$1k$10k$100k0.5×1×2×5×10×2014201620182020202220242026Bitcoin pricePrice against its 2-year average
Top: the price, on a log scale so a doubling is the same height anywhere. It is drawn bold where the measure was in the cheapest or the dearest tenth of everything it had been up to that day. Bottom: the measure, where 1× means the price was exactly at the 2-year average. Four years of history are needed before a place is given, so the bold stretches begin in 2016.

How well has each measure told the year ahead?

Each measure against what Bitcoin did over the following 12 months, in three separate stretches of its history, and what followed its extremes.

Measure Link, up to 20172018 to 20212022 on After its cheapest tenth After its dearest tenth
Price against its 200-week average weakstrongstrong +122%worst +12%, 4 periods −22%best +7%, 1 period
Price against its long-term growth line moderatestrongstrong +154%worst +119%, 1 period −29%best +63%, 2 periods
Bitcoin's value against everything miners have been paid weakstrongstrong never there −29%best +207%, 3 periods
Price against what holders paid nonemoderatemoderate +93%worst −27%, 3 periods −27%best +43%, 2 periods
Price against its 2-year average nonestrongmoderate +90%worst +12%, 2 periods −68%best +49%, 2 periods
Miners' daily income against its yearly average weakstrongnone +95%worst +12%, 3 periods −23%best +177%, 2 periods
Price against its 200-day average noneweakweak, the wrong way round +47%worst −40%, 6 periods −33%best +43%, 3 periods

How to read the table

  • Link: how closely a high reading went with a poor following 12 months, and a low reading with a good one, in words: none, weak, moderate or strong. "The wrong way round" means a high reading was followed by a better year, not a worse one.
  • Three stretches, because a link that holds in only one of them is luck. The first three measures held in all three; the 200-day average did not hold in any.
  • After its cheapest and dearest tenth: the middle result of the next 12 months, with the worst or best case and the number of separate periods behind it. One or two periods is one or two market cycles, not a rule.
  • What these do not do: time a purchase. We tested them as switches for our own strategy’s entries and exits, and none improved it. The following 12 months is a long time, and prices fell a long way inside several of the good ones.

Worked out from Bitcoin’s daily closing prices since 18 Jul 2010 and its fixed release schedule. Miner income counts the new coins released each day at that day’s price, with fees left out. What holders paid: source Coin Metrics. The link is a rank correlation on weekly readings. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. Not advice and not a forecast.

Risk warning Bitcoin and shares are volatile, and their prices can fall sharply and stay low for long periods. Read the full risk warning

Bitcoin and shares are volatile, and their prices can fall sharply and stay low for long periods. Bitcoin Super Intelligence trades spot bitcoin against USDC in your own exchange account, and S&P 500 Super Intelligence trades an S&P 500 index fund (IVV) in your own brokerage account: no leverage, no borrowing, no short selling, no futures and no options. Neither places stop-loss orders, so while a strategy holds its market your balance falls with the price and you may lose a large part of your funds. Funds held at an exchange or a broker also carry that venue's own risks, including outages, account restrictions and insolvency. Past performance shown on this site is the record of each strategy's rules applied to market prices since 1 January 2021 and is not a reliable indicator of future results. Nothing on this site is investment advice. Trade only with money you can afford to lose. By using any Thistle^ service you accept our Terms and Privacy Policy, and you are responsible for all losses in your account.

Thistle^ services are not available where their use would require a licence we do not hold or would be a regulated activity. We do not serve users based in or affiliated to the USA.